Toxic positivity, the act of overemphasizing positive emotions while dismissing negative ones, has become a point of discussion in both personal and public spheres. Recent criticisms, including a complaint from a former employee of actor Justin Baldoni’s company, Wayfarer Studios, have shed light on this phenomenon. The ex-staffer described Baldoni’s unrelenting optimism as “toxic positivity,” a term gaining traction as more people experience the effects of overly upbeat attitudes in their social and professional environments.
While positivity is generally considered beneficial—linked to reduced anxiety, improved immune function, and even greater longevity—its extreme form can be harmful. Experts, including Dr. Deborah Serani, a psychologist and author of Living with Depression, explain that toxic positivity occurs when the emphasis on optimism is so intense that it invalidates real, complex emotions like sadness, anger, or fear. This can lead to emotional avoidance, where individuals push away uncomfortable feelings instead of addressing them.
The roots of toxic positivity are often tied to a lack of emotional tolerance. People who struggle to sit with discomfort may resort to a “sunny” outlook as a coping mechanism, not realizing that it prevents deeper emotional engagement. “It’s important to reflect on all of your emotions, even the negative ones,” says Dr. Natalie Dattilo-Ryan, a clinical psychologist. “Being positive means acknowledging negativity and finding ways to overcome it, rather than pretending it doesn’t exist.”
Signs of toxic positivity may include feelings of discomfort when others express negative emotions or an instinct to “fix” problems rather than listening empathetically. Common phrases like “It’s going to be OK” or “Look on the bright side” may inadvertently shut down important conversations, leaving others feeling alienated.
The effects of toxic positivity extend beyond individual relationships. Studies have shown that excessive optimism can lower emotional resilience, hinder productivity in work and academic settings, and contribute to poor mental health. Suppressing negative emotions can elevate stress and increase the risk of mental health issues over time.
To avoid toxic positivity, experts recommend striking a balance between optimism and authenticity. When negative emotions arise, it’s essential to acknowledge them and provide support through empathy, rather than rushing to offer solutions. Phrases such as “It’s OK to not have everything figured out right now” or “Life can be unfair, and it’s okay to feel upset” help create a space for open, compassionate dialogue. By emphasizing emotional honesty and empathy, we can foster healthier relationships and maintain better mental well-being.
Read more:
