As Medicare open enrollment for 2025 begins, thousands of Minnesota seniors are faced with a difficult decision—stick with their trusted doctors or choose a new health insurance plan. This dilemma comes as major health systems across the state drop from Medicare Advantage networks, causing widespread uncertainty and frustration.
One affected senior, Wendy Sandstrom, a 69-year-old resident of St. Louis Park, shared her frustration. “It’s incredibly annoying,” she said. “It’s either change insurance or go to a different clinic and hospital—and I’m not going to do that. I’ve been going to Park Nicollet since I was in fifth grade.”
Sandstrom’s story is not unique. An estimated 59,000 Minnesotans are facing similar choices as healthcare systems like Park Nicollet, Essentia Health, Avera Health, and others are going out-of-network with major Medicare Advantage providers, including UnitedHealthcare and Humana.
Surge in Disruptions: What’s Driving the Changes?
HealthPartners, the parent company of Park Nicollet, announced its decision in July to go out-of-network with UnitedHealthcare’s Medicare Advantage plan for 2025. As a result, patients like Sandstrom who rely on these plans for affordable healthcare now have to navigate the maze of open enrollment once again.
This growing trend is sparking concern among policy experts. “It really is a profound effect from the enrollee perspective,” says Paul Ginsburg, economist and health policy professor at the University of Southern California. “Seniors, who often stay with the same providers for years, are suddenly faced with disruptions to their care, and this will definitely get their attention.”
Adding to the complexity, other health systems like Duluth-based Essentia Health, North Memorial Health, and Sanford Health are also dropping out of certain Medicare Advantage networks for the coming year, which means higher out-of-pocket costs for many seniors.
Impact on Minnesota’s Senior Population
Medicare open enrollment is a crucial time for seniors to evaluate their health plans, but studies show that many rarely switch coverage. As Ginsburg points out, some seniors may not even realize their network is changing until it’s too late. This could result in patients discovering next year that their long-standing doctors are no longer in-network, leading to frustration and, in some cases, unaffordable care.
In response to these changes, patients are left with limited options: either switch to a different health plan or pay more out-of-pocket to continue seeing their current doctors. For those like Sandstrom, the idea of switching doctors is a non-starter. “I can’t imagine changing clinics at this stage of my life,” she said. “It’s stressful enough trying to navigate Medicare as it is.”
Why Are Health Systems Dropping Out?
While no clear reason has been given for these widespread changes, experts speculate that rising healthcare costs, contract negotiations, and insurance reimbursement rates could be at the core of the issue. Health systems may also be focusing on restructuring their networks to cut costs, leaving patients caught in the crossfire.
The decision by healthcare providers to drop Medicare Advantage plans from their networks reflects a broader challenge in the U.S. healthcare system: finding ways to balance affordability for patients with the financial sustainability of health systems.
Consequences of Network Disruptions
Patients enrolled in out-of-network plans could face several challenges:
Increased Costs: Without coverage, patients will have to pay out-of-pocket for services, potentially driving up their healthcare expenses significantly.
Limited Access: Some health systems have started denying appointments to patients whose Medicare Advantage plans do not have network contracts in place.
Quality of Care: Seniors who switch health plans may find it difficult to receive the same level of care they were accustomed to with their long-standing doctors and clinics.
The changes highlight a growing tension between insurers and healthcare providers, with patients bearing the brunt of these disruptions.
How Seniors Can Navigate These Changes
Experts advise seniors facing Medicare plan changes to:
Review Plans Thoroughly: Take the time to evaluate the available plans during open enrollment to ensure coverage of preferred doctors and services.
Speak with Healthcare Providers: Check with doctors and clinics to see which health plans they are accepting for the upcoming year.
Seek Help: Medicare counselors and online resources can guide seniors through the decision-making process.
“It’s important for seniors to stay proactive and informed during open enrollment,” Ginsburg says. “Waiting until after changes take place can lead to unpleasant surprises.”
Room for Improvement
While the US healthcare system continues to struggle with network disruptions, experts agree that there are ways to improve the situation. Increasing transparency between insurers and healthcare providers, improving contract negotiations, and enhancing preventive healthcare measures could reduce the frequency and impact of these changes.
“Both healthcare systems and insurers need to find a way to collaborate better,” Ginsburg concludes. “The goal should always be to provide the best care possible for the patient, and right now, these network disruptions are undermining that goal.”
Conclusion
As Minnesota seniors gear up for Medicare open enrollment, the healthcare landscape is rapidly changing, and many are facing difficult decisions. Whether to switch plans or doctors, the stakes are high for those who rely on Medicare Advantage. In the coming weeks, seniors will need to stay informed, seek guidance, and carefully consider their options to ensure they can continue receiving the care they trust.
Read more:
Study Highlights Health Disparities Between US And UK Adults
New Research Suggests Weight Management May Preserve Brain Health With Age
New Guidelines Released For Strengthening Maternal And Newborn Health Services
