As health officials worldwide continue to issue stark warnings about alcohol consumption, U.S. guidelines remain a point of contention, with American health recommendations conflicting with those of other nations. Recent findings by the World Health Organization (WHO) and studies globally emphasize that there is no safe level of alcohol consumption, yet U.S. public health messages still suggest moderate drinking is relatively safe for adults. This divergence has raised concerns among health experts and policy advocates, especially as the U.S. prepares for its next round of Dietary Guidelines revisions in 2025.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s upcoming review of alcohol’s effects on health has been met with increasing scrutiny. According to a recent analysis from The New York Times, while many countries are taking a firm stance against alcohol use—citing risks even at low levels—the U.S. continues to promote the idea that moderate drinking may offer benefits, particularly for heart health. This stance has come under fire as evidence accumulates linking alcohol consumption with various health risks, including cancer, liver disease, and mental health disorders.
A recent report from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, commissioned by the USDA, does acknowledge that excessive drinking and binge drinking have well-documented harms. However, it also notes that moderate drinking—defined as up to one drink per day for women and two for men—may still be linked to lower all-cause mortality rates and a reduced risk of cardiovascular events. But critics argue that these findings do not sufficiently address the growing body of evidence linking alcohol to multiple forms of cancer, including breast and liver cancer.
Globally, health guidelines are becoming stricter, with countries such as Canada and the UK adjusting their recommendations to reflect newer research showing that alcohol consumption, even at low levels, poses health risks. The WHO has been particularly vocal, classifying alcohol as a carcinogen and warning that no level of drinking is entirely safe. In 2023, Canada released updated guidelines stating that no amount of alcohol is risk-free, and even small amounts could cause damage to health, regardless of age, sex, or lifestyle.
Dr. Spencer Hansen, an addiction psychiatrist, underscores the increasing concern about alcohol’s long-term impact on physical and mental health. He explains, “The idea that moderate drinking offers health benefits is now being seriously questioned. We’re seeing an increase in alcohol-related cancers, heart disease, and liver damage. Even small amounts of alcohol can increase the risk of these diseases.”
One of the most alarming health risks associated with alcohol consumption is its link to cancer. WHO reports that alcohol consumption is responsible for 4.4% of cancer cases globally. In the U.S. alone, alcohol-related cancers account for more than 75,000 cases annually, with breast cancer being the most common form of alcohol-related cancer among women. Studies have shown that even moderate alcohol intake increases the risk of certain cancers, yet U.S. guidelines have not fully embraced this concern, continuing to promote moderate drinking as a relatively low-risk behavior.
The U.S. 2020 Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee recommended reducing alcohol consumption to one drink a day for both men and women, acknowledging alcohol’s role as a carcinogen. However, this recommendation was not fully adopted in the final guidelines, which still permit up to two drinks a day for men. This discrepancy has raised concerns that the alcohol industry’s influence may be shaping public health recommendations.
The U.S. is also grappling with a rise in alcohol-related deaths. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reports a staggering 29% increase in alcohol-related fatalities between 2020 and 2021. This uptick followed a broader trend of rising alcohol consumption during the pandemic, highlighting the urgent need for a more accurate portrayal of alcohol’s risks.
Critics, including health policy advocates, point out that the alcohol industry’s influence on research and policy decisions may skew the public’s understanding of alcohol’s health impacts. Marion Nestle, author of Unsavory Truth, has written extensively on how industry funding can influence scientific findings, noting that some studies which found health benefits from moderate drinking were funded by the alcohol industry itself.
As the U.S. revises its Dietary Guidelines in 2025, experts argue that the country needs to re-evaluate its stance on alcohol. The increasing body of evidence linking alcohol to various health risks, including cancer and liver disease, should prompt a reevaluation of the current recommendations. Experts like Diane Riibe, cofounder of the U.S. Alcohol Policy Alliance, advocate for stricter guidelines that reflect the growing scientific consensus about alcohol’s dangers.
Meanwhile, experts such as Randall Carlisle from Odyssey House of Utah emphasize the importance of moderation and self-awareness in alcohol consumption. “It’s crucial to recognize when alcohol consumption is becoming problematic, especially for those with a family history of alcoholism or mental health issues,” he says.
The ongoing debate about alcohol’s role in public health highlights the need for more transparent and evidence-based messaging from U.S. health authorities. As global guidelines shift to reflect the reality that no level of alcohol consumption is entirely safe, it’s essential for the U.S. to align its recommendations with the growing body of scientific evidence.
The message is clear: reducing alcohol intake, and in some cases eliminating it altogether, can significantly improve health outcomes. It’s time for the U.S. to reconsider its stance and adopt more health-conscious guidelines that prioritize public well-being over industry interests.
Read more:
Alcohol And Health: The Controversy Behind U.S. Dietary Guidelines And Public Health
Cheese Up, Milk Down: The Impact Of Changing Dairy Habits On Our Health
How Eating More Plants And Exercising Could Reverse Your Biological Age
